Friday, June 19, 2009

Meanor Beginnings Vol. 1 Issue 2

If William Meanor (wife Ellen Hamilton) is the son of William and Margaret Smith Meanor, he had to have been born earlier than the date given, because William Meanor (wife Racheal Peart) was born 6 years prior to the date given for the first William's date of birth. Even reversing the birthdates wouldn't explain the difference.

I don't know how much of the Meanor Beginnings I am going to be able to trust if this is an example of their research. I'll press though a couple of years and see where it goes, or if the quality of information improves. It definatly calls for verifications.

There seems to be some questions about Isaac's chidren that are not resolved in this newsletter. So it makes it even doublly hard to trust anything in the newsletter. The newsletter opens by giving strong first and secondary sources, but quickly drops into speculation with no clues as to what is fact and what is fiction.

I need more solid evidence that is more carefully documented and reported. Nothing personal Grace....I just can't see where your coming from.

No comments:

Post a Comment